From First-Timer to Faithful: How to Get and Keep New Students

Ryne Caudle • January 2, 2024

From First-Timer to Faithful: How to Get and Keep New Students | Beyond the Youth Room • Episode 12

In Episode 12, youth pastors Keith and Ryne discuss how you can help new students feel at home in your ministry, and create an environment where students want to invite their friends!


👉 Episode Highlights:


📈 Quick Tips on How to Grow Your Youth Group

⚙️ Practical Ways to Implement a New Student Follow-Up Process

1️⃣ How a Single Student Revolutionized a Ministry

🏫 The Importance of Investing in Students Outside of Youth Group


🎙️ Subscribe now for weekly episodes packed with practical tips, real-life stories, and expert interviews to supercharge your youth ministry!

By Ellen Hembree January 27, 2026
Overwhelmed in Youth Ministry? 5 Things to Cut to Protect Margin
By Ellen Hembree January 27, 2026
What Dave Ramsey Can Teach Us About Youth Ministry Growth
By Ellen Hembree January 20, 2026
Why So Many Youth Ministries Stall at 10–25 Students (and How to Move Forward)
By Ellen Hembree January 13, 2026
Navigating the Schooling Debate: A Youth Pastor’s Perspective on Public, Private, and Homeschooling
By Ellen Hembree January 6, 2026
TikTok Theology: Training Students for Digital Discernment
By Ellen Hembree December 16, 2025
Your Church Has a Leadership Personality (And It Shapes Your Youth Ministry)
By Ellen Hembree December 9, 2025
Panic or Patience? What to Do When Youth Ministry Growth Slows
By Ellen Hembree December 2, 2025
5 Youth Ministry Trends That Will Shape 2026 (and how to get ready) 
By Ellen Hembree November 25, 2025
Why So Many Students Are Deconstructing—And What You Can Do About It
By Ellen Hembree November 18, 2025
Millennials, Gen Z, and the Bible: Why Young Adults Are Fueling a Scripture Comeback