Why Don't More Ministries Succeed When They're Short-Staffed? | Beyond the Youth Room Pod • Ep 42

Ellen Hembree • July 30, 2024

This is a subtitle for your new post

Welcome to another episode of the Beyond the Youth Room podcast! I’m Keith, and joining me is Ryne. Today, we’re tackling a common issue in youth ministries: why don't more ministries succeed when they're short-staffed? Stay tuned!


The Shortage of Leaders in Youth Ministries

Youth ministries across the country are facing a shortage of leaders. This issue spans different roles, from full-time youth pastors to part-time and volunteer leaders. Many of you might be in a similar situation, feeling the strain of not having enough hands on deck. Ryne and I both work in churches and experience this firsthand. Right now, for example, we have about one volunteer for every 12-13 kids in our ministry.


The Importance of Replicating Leaders

In ministry, replicating leaders is crucial. If we want to grow and disciple more students, we need more leaders. Ryne,  has had a significant increase in student conversions this past year - 84, to be exact! - and this kind of growth is fantastic, but it also means we need more leaders to disciple these new believers.


Setting Realistic Ratios

An ideal leader-to-student ratio can vary. While some ministries might manage with 1 leader to 12 students, others may need a lower ratio depending on the context. The key is to ensure leaders are effective and committed.


Challenges and Solutions

  1. Vision and Mentality: Ministries often limit themselves by their current resources. Instead, set a bold vision and recruit towards it. Believe that God will provide the necessary leaders to accomplish His mission.
  2. Prioritizing the Right Tasks: Many leaders delegate crucial tasks like teaching the Word. Focus on what matters most: prayer and the ministry of the Word. Delegate administrative tasks to volunteers to free up time for spiritual responsibilities.
  3. Setting Realistic Expectations: Be honest about what your ministry can achieve with the current resources. Sometimes, taking a step back in certain areas allows other crucial areas to flourish.
  4. Leveraging Student Leaders: Student leaders can be a significant asset. Our middle school community, for example, is led primarily by high school students. They take on leadership roles, facilitating discussions and mentoring younger students.


Practical Tips for Recruiting Leaders

  1. Observe Potential Leaders: Watch for faithfulness in potential leaders. Are they committed to other church activities? Do they exhibit humility and a servant’s heart?
  2. Set a Bold Vision: Communicate a bold vision to potential leaders. Share the mission and ask them to pray about joining. This approach makes them feel valued and part of something significant.


Traits to Look for in Leaders

  1. Humility: Humility is crucial. Leaders should be willing to serve in any capacity, understanding that no task is beneath them.


Leveraging Data

Collect data to show the impact of your ministry. Numbers like how many students have trusted Christ or been baptized can help justify the need for more leaders and resources.


Conclusion

Being short-staffed doesn’t mean your ministry can’t succeed. By focusing on the right things, setting realistic expectations, and leveraging your current resources wisely, you can still make a significant impact.



Thank you for joining us on today's episode. If you found this content helpful, please share it and interact with it on social media. If you're listening on a podcast platform, make sure to subscribe so you don’t miss future episodes. And if you’re watching on YouTube, please subscribe to our channel. Sharing our content is one of the best compliments you can give us. Thank you for your support, and we’ll see you next time!

By Ellen Hembree January 27, 2026
Overwhelmed in Youth Ministry? 5 Things to Cut to Protect Margin
By Ellen Hembree January 27, 2026
What Dave Ramsey Can Teach Us About Youth Ministry Growth
By Ellen Hembree January 20, 2026
Why So Many Youth Ministries Stall at 10–25 Students (and How to Move Forward)
By Ellen Hembree January 13, 2026
Navigating the Schooling Debate: A Youth Pastor’s Perspective on Public, Private, and Homeschooling
By Ellen Hembree January 6, 2026
TikTok Theology: Training Students for Digital Discernment
By Ellen Hembree December 16, 2025
Your Church Has a Leadership Personality (And It Shapes Your Youth Ministry)
By Ellen Hembree December 9, 2025
Panic or Patience? What to Do When Youth Ministry Growth Slows
By Ellen Hembree December 2, 2025
5 Youth Ministry Trends That Will Shape 2026 (and how to get ready) 
By Ellen Hembree November 25, 2025
Why So Many Students Are Deconstructing—And What You Can Do About It
By Ellen Hembree November 18, 2025
Millennials, Gen Z, and the Bible: Why Young Adults Are Fueling a Scripture Comeback